A student wants to investigate how the acceleration of a trolley depends on the resultant force acting on it.
She has a trolley, a bench pulley, string, a mass hanger with slotted masses (each of weight 1.0 N), a metre rule, a piece of card that can be fixed to the trolley, and a light gate connected to a data logger.
Describe a method she could use. Include how she would make sure the investigation is valid. [6]
- attach trolley to the hanger by string passing over the pulley at the edge of the bench(1)
- release trolley from rest from the same starting point each time(1)
- use the light gate/data logger to measure the acceleration (allow: measure the speed at the light gate and the distance from the start with the metre rule and use v² = 2as; or measure speed at two points and the time between them)(1)
- use the metre rule to keep the distance from the start position to the light gate the same each time(1)
- fix a double (segmented) interrupt card to the trolley so a single light gate/data logger can record two speeds and the time between them to give the acceleration(1)
- the weight of the hanging masses provides the accelerating (resultant) force(1)
- change the force by moving masses from the trolley to the hanger one at a time(1)
- keep the total mass of the system constant (masses not on the hanger stay on the trolley)(1)
- repeat each force several times and calculate a mean acceleration(1)
- compensate for friction, e.g. tilt the surface slightly (allow: place the trolley on a runway raised at one end) so the trolley just moves at constant speed when given a small push(1)
- plot a graph of acceleration against force(1)
- place a box/soft surface under the hanging masses to catch them (safety)(1)
Level Marks What it looks like Level 3 5–6 A clear, logically ordered method that would let someone else carry out the investigation and obtain valid results; how force is varied and acceleration measured are both explained, with the mass kept constant. Level 2 3–4 Most key steps are described; there may be gaps or an unclear order, and control of mass or measurement of acceleration may be incomplete. Level 1 1–2 Some relevant steps are given but the method is fragmented and would not produce valid results. No relevant content 0 Nothing worthy of credit. - Answer: Accelerating force = weight on the hanger; move 1.0 N slotted masses from trolley to hanger to change the force while the total mass stays constant; measure acceleration with the light gate; repeat and take means; plot a against F.
- Examiner tip: Validity means keeping the TOTAL accelerating mass constant — the masses taken off the hanger must go back on the trolley.